Dog V Cat People

I want to weigh in on this whole cat people versus dog people debate, because I think it is just a bunch of poppycock, and sorry no, I don’t actually know what poppycock is. Pitting one stereotype against another to determine which self-identifiable group really has life figured out? Come on people. But just for those who have been suckered by the diabolical plot to divide animal lovers from one another I have dug into the research on this phenomena and come up with, pretty much poppycock…

On the Google thing you all rely upon for “facts” there were many references to a study that was done back in 2014 using a survey of 650 college students. Now there is a diverse study pool (insert eye roll emoji here). The scary thing was that this “research study” was referenced in a factual manner by a number of other news articles on this topic.

For example the results were factually offered by CBS News, stating that people who identified as dog lovers tended to be more lively, energetic and outgoing, yet rule followers. Self-identified cat lovers, on the other hand, were concluded to be more introverted, open-minded and sensitive than dog lovers. Results also rated cat people as non-conformists.

Is it lost on anyone that these characteristics of dog or cat people are the same basic stereotypical differences between dogs and cats? Oh but wait there is more, this study (and the many subsequent articles on it) also claimed that cat lovers scored higher on intelligence than dog lovers (ok, as a feline I have to appreciate this a little bit, that you have to be dumb to be a dog person, even though it is clearly rubbish).

As I scoured the Google thing, the only other “research” I was able to uncover was a reference to a survey done by a pet product company, no conflict of interest there, that only leads to an error page if you try to read the actual study. The article referencing this “survey” makes ludicrous claims like, “dog owners are more likely to work in finance and cat owners are more likely to work in a creative field” or “dog owners prefer horror and action films while cat owners prefer documentaries.”

So dog people are cerebral financiers who prefer violence while cat people are creative intellects? Yeah Google. So what about people who like both dogs and cats, where to they fit in all of this? Are they dim, untalented and unsuccessful?

So here is my suggestion, how about you all just remove the boxes and let each other just be people with varying interests and characteristics who may or may not like pets. Does it all have to mean something or can you just celebrate each other’s differences and uniqueness? Maybe just be who you are and let others do the same.

My name is Tamale (you say Tomato, I say Tamale), a gorgeous1 year young curious, quiet, heart-stealing girl looking for my forever home. I love making new friends, including dogs and cats, and celebrating everyone’s differences. Call the Second Chance Shelter for an appointment to meet me today!

By the way, the Google thing said that poppycock comes from the old Dutch expression zo fijn als gemalen poppekak, translating to “as fine as powdered doll’s excrement.”

Second Chance Humane Society’s Animal Resource Center and Thrift Shops have been servicing San Miguel, Ouray & Montrose Counties for over 26 years. Call 626-2273 to report a lost pet, learn about adopting a homeless pet, or about our Emergency Response, Community Medical, Spay/Neuter, Volunteer, or other services. View our shelter pets and services online:


Second Chance Humane Society Animal Resource Center and Thrift Shops service San Miguel, Ouray and Montrose counties. Call the SCHS Helpline at 970-626-2273 to report a lost pet or to learn about adopting a homeless pet and the SCHS spay/neuter, volunteer, feral cat or other programs. View our shelter pets and services at

Our animals


Friend is a great cat that just wants to go to a home and be with someone that will cuddle...


Timon is kinda shy but would like someone to play toys with and to cuddle with. We highly encourage calling...


It's Kitten Season!!!!! We have a bunch of little kittens awaiting their forever homes! Ranging in colors, sex, and personality...


Buddy is a 5 year old beautiful and sweet Mix breed. He is very friendly and well behaved. He loves...


Louise is a beautiful Border Collie mix and she is about 1 1/2 years old. Louise is very sweet, loving...


Meet Jack! Jack is a 4 to 5 year old Shepherd Mix awaiting his forever home! He loves to go...

Second Chance Humane Society

Animal Resource Center

Ridgway Thrift

Telluride Thrift

Shelter Hours

Open Tuesday - Saturday

Animal Resource Center
11 am - 6 pm

Cat Castle
11 am - 6 pm

Dog Den
11 am - 5:45 pm

2021, Second Chance Humane Society
Managed by PMC